Charter on Music Creation

This version is currently being reviewed.
Changes may therefore occur at any time.
Charter established on August 13, 2026
1 • Preamble – Purpose of the Charter

1.1. Purpose and Objective of the Charter
The purpose of this charter is to clearly, transparently, and comprehensively formalize the principles governing musical creation, production, recording, publishing, and, more broadly, the development of works produced within the framework of this artistic project. It serves as a reference document intended to describe the conditions under which the works are conceived and produced, as well as the principles governing their creative process. In particular, it aims to provide sufficiently precise information on the origin of the creations, the methods employed, and the nature of human interventions that led to the final result. This approach seeks to ensure an unambiguous understanding of the artistic process, both for those directly involved in the project and for partners, distributors, publishers, platforms, professional organizations, or any third party that may need to assess the origin or conditions of the works’ creation.

1.2. Fundamental Principle of the Absence of Generative Artificial Intelligence
This charter is based on a fundamental principle: the musical creation in question is produced without the use of a generative artificial intelligence tool or an artificial intelligence system involved in the artistic creation process. The compositions, melodies, harmonies, arrangements, lyrics (where applicable), artistic choices, interpretations, decision-making, musical direction, and other constituent elements of the works are the result of a human process. No artificial intelligence system is used to generate, propose, transform, or co-produce the creative elements intended to constitute the works. This clarification is provided to explicitly characterize the creative process and to avoid any misinterpretation regarding the origin of the various elements comprising the works in question.

1.3. Strictly Informational Scope of the Charter
This charter does not constitute a general statement of principle on artificial intelligence, nor does it represent a position aimed at pitting human creativity against the use of artificial intelligence technologies in the field of music. It is not intended to fuel a debate on the advantages, limitations, legitimacy, or evolution of these technologies. Its purpose is more narrowly defined: to accurately describe the process actually used for the works in question. The statement that AI was not used should therefore be understood as information regarding the project’s creative methods and not as a judgment on the practices of other artists, producers, or creators. This distinction allows the charter to remain strictly factual and documentary in nature.

1.4. Definition of the Absence of AI Intervention
To avoid any ambiguity, the absence of the use of artificial intelligence must be understood as the absence of intervention by an AI system in the design or generation of the artistic elements that constitute the works. The creative process therefore does not rely on the automatic generation of music, melodies, harmonies, lyrics, arrangements, sounds, performances, or artistic content intended to be incorporated into the works. Creative decisions are made by the individuals participating in the project, based on their knowledge, experience, artistic choices, and working methods. Technical tools that may be used in the context of music production should not be confused, solely because of their digital or computer-based nature, with artificial intelligence tools: this charter thus distinguishes between the use of traditional technical tools for production, recording, editing, or sound processing and the use of a system that performs a function of generation or creative contribution through artificial intelligence.

1.5. Traceability and Documentation of the Creative Process
This charter also aims to ensure sufficient traceability of the creative process. It establishes a framework that allows, when necessary, for the identification of the various stages of work, human interventions, and methods used to arrive at successive versions of the works. It thus aims to promote consistent and sustainable documentation of the project, regardless of technological developments or practices in the music industry. The elements described in the various chapters of the charter should be considered complementary: they are intended to progressively clarify the principles applicable to writing, composition, arrangement, performance, recording, production, publishing, and any technical operations that may occur during the process.

1.6. Clarification and Prevention of Ambiguities
Finally, this charter aims to clarify matters and prevent ambiguities. It is intended to enable anyone who consults or evaluates the project to understand, to the extent necessary, the conditions under which the works were created and the principles guiding their production process. It does not seek to establish any specific presumption, to provide a legal classification of the works on its own, or to supersede any legal, contractual, or regulatory provisions that may apply to them. Above all, it constitutes a voluntary documentation of the artistic process and the commitments that frame it. Any statement contained in this charter is intended to correspond to the practices actually followed within the framework of the project and to be capable of being clarified or documented by the available working materials when relevant.

1.7. Revisions and Updates to the Charter
This charter may be supplemented or updated as required by changes in the project, working methods, or technical framework. Any changes must, however, preserve the principle of transparency that forms its foundation: the actual conditions under which the works are created must remain distinguishable and understandable. In this sense, this charter is not merely a declarative text; it constitutes a framework intended to establish a clear distinction between human contributions, the technical tools used to implement them, and—when such a question arises—artificial intelligence technologies that do not participate in the creative process described here.

2 • Fundamental Principles of Creation

2.1. A Personal, Deliberate, and Human Approach
Musical creation is based first and foremost on a personal, deliberate, and human approach. Each work is conceived from a unique artistic intention, a sensibility, experiences, reflections, and choices made throughout the creative process. Composition, writing, arrangement, performance, and the various artistic decisions involved in the development of a work are the result of personal effort and a series of choices made by its creator. This approach implies that the work is not conceived as a mere reproduction of a pre-existing result, but as the culmination of a process in which an identifiable artistic intention is gradually developed, refined, and given form.

2.2. Originality and Personal Expression
Originality is an important principle of this approach. It should not be understood as an obligation to create in the complete absence of influences—which would be unrealistic in the artistic realm—but rather as the pursuit of a unique form of expression through the way in which various musical elements are selected, combined, and developed. Every creative work is necessarily part of a musical history, encompassing movements, genres, practices, and references that can fuel inspiration. However, the influences and references that contribute to the creative process do not, in and of themselves, constitute an intention to reproduce an existing work. The goal is to transform these contributions into a personal, coherent, and identifiable artistic expression, while respecting the works, authors, and performers whose work may have helped shape the creator’s thinking or musical culture.

2.3. Research and Artistic Expression
Artistic expression lies at the heart of the process. Choices regarding composition, timbre, structure, rhythm, interpretation, arrangement, production, and sound processing are made to serve a specific musical intention. Musical exploration is an integral part of this process: experimenting, trying different approaches, questioning an initial idea, exploring a sound, modifying a structure, or seeking another way to express the same intention are all considered normal stages of the creative process. A work can thus evolve considerably between its initial concept and its final version. Trials, errors, hesitations, corrections, and successive transformations all contribute to the construction of the work’s identity and reflect a process of exploration rather than the mere execution of a predetermined result.

2.4. Artistic Coherence
Coherence is another essential principle. The various choices made during the creative process must, as much as possible, serve a recognizable artistic direction and contribute to the work’s overall identity. This coherence may relate to composition, writing, performance, arrangement, timbre, production, or even the aesthetic choices associated with the project. It does not necessarily imply uniformity or an absence of contrast: a work may intentionally include breaks, contrasts, or significant shifts, provided that these result from an artistic intention. The coherence sought is therefore, above all, that of the artistic vision and choices, with each element considered in terms of its contribution to the whole.

2.5. Technical Standards and Quality of Execution
Technical standards go hand in hand with artistic standards. The pursuit of personal expression does not exempt one from paying close attention to the quality of the works’ production. Recording, editing, arranging, sound processing, mixing, mastering, and other technical operations are carried out with a view to preserving and serving the artistic intent. The technical tools used in this context are considered means of giving concrete form to human choices: their use alone does not constitute an autonomous creative intervention. Particular attention is thus paid to the quality of the performances, the precision of the recordings, the clarity of the arrangements, the sound balance, and, more generally, to mastery of the various stages necessary to produce a finished work.

2.6. Respect for Performers
Respect for performers is also a fundamental principle of the creative process. When a work involves one or more performers, their contribution is considered an integral part of the artistic process and cannot be reduced to a mere performance function. Performers bring their sensitivity, technique, musicality, and artistic choices to the framework provided to them. Their work must be carried out under conditions that respect their contribution and artistic integrity, and their role must be distinguishable from any technical tools used for recording or production. Any modifications, edits, or processing that may occur after recording must serve the work and must not be intended to conceal the true nature of the performer’s contribution.

2.7. Respect for Existing Works and Artistic Influences
Respect for existing works and artistic influences is a complementary principle. Musical creation can take place within a rich cultural and artistic environment, and a creator may be influenced by the works they listen to, the artists they admire, the techniques they study, or the musical movements to which they are exposed. These influences can fuel the creative process, but they are neither a necessary condition for creation nor an obligation for the creator to identify an external source for every element of their work. A creation may also result from a personal approach, research, experimentation, or artistic choices specific to the creator.

2.8. Distinction Between Inspiration, Reference, and Reproduction
When influences or references exist, they must not be confused with an attempt to claim as one’s own a creation that belongs to another. The approach involves distinguishing between inspiration, learning, aesthetic or technical references, and the reproduction or direct use of elements from a pre-existing work. The works, artists, and contributions that may have influenced one’s artistic journey are treated with respect, without their existence implying that a new creation is necessarily linked to them.

2.9. Transparency of the Creative Process
Finally, transparency of the process is the overarching principle of this entire charter. Works must be describable based on their actual creative process, without presenting contributions as human when they are not, and without attributing to technical tools a role they did not play. Within the framework defined by this charter, no generative artificial intelligence or AI system designed to produce an artistic contribution is used to create the constituent elements of the works. This statement concerns the process actually followed and is not intended to pass judgment on the practices of other creators. It aims solely to establish a clear distinction between human choices and contributions, the technical tools used to implement them, and automated generation systems that do not participate in the creative process described in this charter.

3 • Human Creation and the Absence of Artificial Intelligence

3.1. Principle of Human Creation
The creation of the works covered by this charter is based exclusively on a human artistic process. The various elements that make up the works are conceived, determined, and developed by their creator through a process grounded in the creator’s knowledge, experience, sensibility, intentions, and artistic decisions. No generative artificial intelligence, no artificial intelligence system designed to produce musical or artistic content, and no automated creative content generation process is involved in the design of the works. The final result thus stems from a process in which responsibility for creative choices and artistic direction remains entirely human.

3.2. Composition, Melody, and Harmony
Compositions are conceived by their creators, who determine their structure, development, organization, and musical identity. Melodies are written by their creators, as are the musical lines and motifs that contribute to the construction of the works. Harmonies are also determined by the composer, who selects the chords, progressions, harmonic relationships, and any necessary developments required to realize their musical intent. These elements are not generated by an artificial intelligence system and then selected or adapted for inclusion in the works; they result directly from the composer’s decisions and creative process.

3.3. Arrangements and Orchestration
Arrangements and orchestration are also products of human creativity. The composer determines how the various musical parts are organized, distributed, and articulated, as well as the instruments, registers, timbres, textures, dynamics, and sound combinations used to shape the work. When multiple instruments or parts are involved, their respective roles, interactions, and development throughout the piece are determined as part of the human creative process. Orchestration is therefore not the result of an automatic proposal generated by artificial intelligence, but rather of musical reflection and choices made by the composer.

3.4. Writing and Transcribing Sheet Music
Sheet music is written and/or transcribed by the composer when it is necessary for the process of creating, preparing, performing, or documenting the work. Musical notation thus constitutes the formalization of a work or a musical intention previously conceived by the creator. It may, of course, be produced using notation software or a computer environment, provided that this tool serves as a means of transcription, editing, or formatting and does not generate artistic content intended to be incorporated into the work. The use of a digital medium or software, therefore, does not in and of itself alter the human origin of the composition or score.

3.5. Artistic Choices
All artistic choices are made by the creator. This includes, in particular, choices regarding style, composition, form, tempo, rhythm, timbre, instruments, performance, arrangement, orchestration, structure, any sound processing, and the overall identity of the work. The decisions made during the process can be numerous and evolve over time: an initial idea may be modified, abandoned, rebuilt, or developed repeatedly. These changes are normal stages of the creative process and remain human decisions, even when facilitated by technical production or recording tools.

3.6. Production Decisions
Production decisions are also made by the creator. They include, in particular, recording conditions, the selection of takes, interpretive choices, editing, sound processing, mixing choices, balance, effects, spatialization, dynamics, as well as the general direction leading to the final version of the work. The potential use of software, digital audio workstations, electronic instruments, processors, effects, or other production equipment should be understood as the use of tools under the creator’s control. These tools enable the implementation, recording, modification, or finalization of human decisions; they are not considered authors or co-creators of the work.

3.7. Distinction Between a Technical Tool and a Creative Generation System
This charter thus establishes a fundamental distinction between technical tools and creative generation systems. Software or equipment used to record, edit, notate, process, mix, organize, or reproduce content does not, by the mere fact of its digital or automated operation, constitute artificial intelligence participating in the creative process. Conversely, no system whose function is to generate—based on an instruction, an analysis, or algorithmic learning—a melody, harmony, arrangement, orchestration, composition, performance, or any other artistic element intended to be incorporated into works is used in the process described by this charter. This distinction allows for a factual description of the process without equating conventional music production tools with generative artificial intelligence technologies.

3.8. Criterion of the Absence of Artificial Intelligence
The absence of artificial intelligence therefore directly concerns the creative process itself, rather than the presence of digital tools in the work environment. A work may be created, recorded, edited, notated, and finalized using computer technologies while still being entirely the product of a human process, provided that the decisive artistic choices and creative content are conceived and controlled by the creator. The criterion adopted by this charter is thus the origin of creative decisions and content: compositions, melodies, harmonies, arrangements, orchestrations, scores, artistic choices, and production decisions are created or determined by the creator, without any creative contribution generated by artificial intelligence.

3.9. Purpose and Scope of the Statement
The purpose of this statement is to clearly document the actual conditions under which the works were created and to prevent any ambiguity regarding their origin. It does not constitute an assessment of the value, legitimacy, or quality of works created using artificial intelligence technologies by other creators. Its sole purpose is to establish a characteristic specific to the process documented by this charter: the works in question are the result of human creation and do not include any creative contribution generated by artificial intelligence in their design or production process.

4 • Tools Used in the Creative Process

4.1. Distinction Between Technical Tools and Generative Artificial Intelligence
The creative process may rely on various software, hardware, and technological tools designed to design, write, record, edit, produce, process, mix, and finalize works. This charter clearly distinguishes these technical tools from generative artificial intelligence systems. The use of software, an electronic instrument, or a computer environment does not, in and of itself, constitute an intervention by artificial intelligence in the creative process. These tools are used as means of execution, notation, recording, processing, or production under the creator’s control. Artistic decisions and key choices thus remain the responsibility of the creator, regardless of the digital or computational nature of the tool used.

4.2. Categories of Tools Used
As part of the creative process, tools such as music notation software, digital audio workstations (DAWs), virtual instruments, orchestral libraries, virtual synthesizers, a MIDI keyboard, audio mixing and processing software, mastering tools, audio effects, sound samples, and various recording tools may be used. This list describes the major categories of tools that may be involved in the process but does not constitute an exhaustive inventory of the entire technical environment used. Their function is to enable the creator to implement their musical decisions, record them, organize them, modify them, and finalize them.

4.3. The Role of Different Tools in the Creative Process
Music notation software can be used, in particular, to write, read, edit, or transcribe a score. DAWs can be used for recording, editing, arranging, programming, processing, and mixing. Virtual instruments, virtual synthesizers, and orchestral libraries can enable the creator to produce or reproduce sounds that correspond to the instrumentation and orchestration choices they have previously determined. A MIDI keyboard can serve as a control or performance interface, allowing the creator to transmit musical information—whether played or programmed—to the software. Audio effects, mixing software, and mastering tools, meanwhile, can be used to process and finalize recordings. In all these cases, the tool serves as a technical means to support human intent and decisions.

4.4. Sound Samples and Pre-existing Audio Resources
Sound samples and other audio resources that may be used in the process must be distinguished from the artistic creation itself. When a sample, loop, texture, sound, or audio resource is used, its role in the work depends on how it is selected, integrated, transformed, and organized by the creator. This charter does not consider the existence of a pre-existing audio resource to be a contribution of artificial intelligence. However, the terms of use, licenses, authorizations, and any restrictions associated with these resources must be respected regardless of this charter. When a resource is likely to raise a specific issue regarding its terms of use or origin, that issue must be examined separately in accordance with applicable rights.

4.5. Confidentiality of the Technical Environment and Know-How
This charter is not intended to disclose the entirety of the creator’s technical environment, work methods, or production choices. The list of tool categories mentioned provides general information to help understand the nature of the process, but should not be interpreted as an obligation to systematically reveal commercial references, brands, models, software versions, libraries used, sound banks, presets, processing chains, settings, programming methods, recording techniques, mixing or mastering procedures, or any other element pertaining to the creator’s know-how or proprietary methods. This information may constitute technical, artistic, or professional elements whose disclosure is not necessary for understanding the fundamental principle established by this charter.

4.6. Disclosure of Detailed Technical Information
Where necessary, detailed technical information may therefore be kept confidential and disclosed only in the appropriate context, particularly when required by a contractual, professional, administrative, or legal obligation. This policy does not, in and of itself, constitute a general authorization to access work files, DAW projects, source scores, recording sessions, settings, presets, effects chains, MIDI files, libraries, sound resources, production documents, or other internal elements of the creative process. Any disclosure of such materials is subject to a separate decision and must, where applicable, be governed by the relevant confidentiality obligations.

Consequently, the use of a tool belonging to one of the categories mentioned above should not be interpreted as a delegation of the creative process to that tool. Compositions, melodies, harmonies, arrangements, orchestrations, scores, artistic choices, and production decisions remain the responsibility of the creator, in accordance with the principles established in the preceding sections. Technical tools enable their creation and finalization but are not considered independent artistic contributors. No generative artificial intelligence tools are used to generate the creative elements that constitute the works within the framework of the process described in this charter.

5 • What Is Not Used

5.1. Exclusion of Generative Artificial Intelligence Tools
As part of the creative process described in this charter, no generative artificial intelligence tools are used to design, generate, or produce the artistic elements that make up the works. Specifically excluded from this process are systems capable of autonomously or semi-autonomously generating compositions, melodies, harmonies, arrangements, orchestrations, lyrics, performances, voices, sounds, or other content intended to be incorporated into the works.

5.2. Lack of Artistic Contribution Generated by Artificial Intelligence
Technologies designed to propose or determine, in place of the creator, artistic elements intended to be retained in the work are also not used as sources of creation. Creative decisions remain the responsibility of the creator, who retains control over composition, writing, arrangement, orchestration, performance, and production. No content generated by artificial intelligence is intentionally incorporated into the works as part of the process described in this charter.

5.3. Distinction Between Creative Generation and Technical Automation
This exclusion does not mean that all automated or digital processes are prohibited. Conventional technical functions—such as recording, editing, correction, processing, mixing, mastering, notation, or work organization may be used when they constitute technical means under the creator’s control. The distinction made in this charter is based on the function of the tool: technologies used as technical means of production are distinguished from systems used to generate an artistic contribution.

5.4. Scope of Exclusion
This section thus supplements the preceding provisions by simply establishing that the works in question are not created from artistic content generated by artificial intelligence. Its purpose is not to provide an exhaustive list of all existing or future technologies, but to clearly define the principle applicable to the creative process: no artistic contribution generated by artificial intelligence is used to create the works covered by this charter.

6 • What Remains Entirely Under the Composer’s Control

The process of creating and producing works remains under the direct control of the composer. This control extends to both strictly musical elements and the choices regarding organization, orchestration, notation, and production necessary for the realization of the works.

Any software tools, electronic instruments, production environments, and other technical resources that may be used are working tools that enable the composer to implement their decisions. They do not independently determine the artistic content of the work, nor do they replace the composer in the choices that define its identity.

6.1. Melody
Melodies are created and developed personally by the composer. Their conception is based on musical reflection, artistic intent, and a series of choices made throughout the creative process. The composer determines the notes, motifs, phrases, repetitions, variations, developments, and melodic progressions that contribute to the work’s identity. A melody may be experimented with, modified, simplified, developed, or entirely rewritten during the process; these various stages are part of the composer’s personal creative work. No generative artificial intelligence system is used to propose or generate a melody intended for inclusion in the work.

6.2. Harmony
Harmonic choices are made by the composer personally. The composer determines the chords, progressions, harmonic functions, tensions, resolutions, and any harmonic developments necessary for the musical structure of the work. These decisions may be based on musical knowledge, experimentation, listening, instrumental trials, or any other process related to the composer’s personal work. Any tools used to notate, play, record, or edit these choices do not constitute an independent source of harmonic decision-making.

6.3. Structure
The composer personally decides on the structure of the work. In particular, the composer determines its overall organization, the sequence of the various sections, their relative durations, their repetitions, their transitions, their developments, their contrasts, and their evolution over time. The structure may be developed gradually and undergo numerous modifications before reaching its final form. Choices regarding the introduction, the various sections, developments, transitions, reprises, breaks, and the conclusion are thus based on the composer’s intent and decision. No automated music generation system is used to independently determine the final structure of the work.

6.4. Orchestration
The composer personally selects the instruments and assigns the various voices or musical parts. The composer determines the instrumentation, registers, doubling, combinations of timbres, density, distribution among sections, and the roles assigned to the various instruments within the work. Orchestration can be carried out directly in a score, using a music production environment, or with the aid of virtual instruments and libraries. In all cases, the orchestration choices are determined by the composer. The use of an orchestral library or a virtual instrument is a means of sonically reproducing a previously decided orchestration and does not mean that the tool designed that orchestration.

6.5. Sheet Music
The notation and editing of scores are carried out personally by the composer when they are part of the process of creating or preparing the work. The composer determines the musical information to be transcribed, its organization, and its representation in the score, including notes, rhythms, time signatures, articulations, dynamics, tempos, performance instructions, and other elements necessary for understanding or performing the work. Music notation software may be used as a technical tool to enter, format, edit, reproduce, or print the score. This use does not constitute a delegation of the composition or notation to artificial intelligence: the musical content and notation decisions remain determined by the composer.

6.6. Production
Programming, arrangement, and production remain under the composer’s control. The composer determines the choices necessary to transform the composition into a finished audio production, including track organization, programming of virtual instruments, selection of sounds, arrangement choices, textures, effects, processing, levels, sound recording, editing, and the various steps required to achieve a production consistent with the artistic intent. DAWs, virtual instruments, synthesizers, sound libraries, MIDI keyboards, effects, and other production tools are the technical means used in this context. Their operation may involve automation or technical processes, but these do not transfer responsibility for artistic choices to the software or hardware.

6.7. Mixing and Mastering
Artistic and technical decisions regarding mixing and mastering are made personally by the composer when he or she handles these steps themselves. Mixing may involve, among other things, choices regarding levels, panning, equalization, dynamics, reverb, effects, depth, spatialization, and the overall balance between the various elements of the work. Mastering, for its part, may involve decisions regarding spectral balance, dynamics, overall level, consistency of the final sound, and preparation of the final file. The software and processing techniques used in these operations remain technical tools under the composer’s control. Any automated functions they offer are used as processing tools and do not constitute an independent artistic contribution or a delegation of the final decision.

The composer’s control must therefore be understood as artistic and decision-making control, and not as an obligation to manually perform every technical operation. Certain functions can be automated by the software used, such as calculating a processing effect, applying an effect, formatting a score, audio rendering, or certain editing operations. This does not call into question the principle established by this charter, provided that these functions constitute technical means of execution and that the decisive decisions regarding the content and identity of the work remain made and validated by the composer. The fundamental distinction therefore rests on the origin of artistic choices: these remain human, personal, and under the composer’s control.

7 • What Remains Entirely Under the Composer’s Control

The composer’s relationship with the instrument is an integral part of the creative process. Discovering its characteristics, learning its possibilities, exploring its limitations, and identifying its expressive resources all play a direct role in the construction of musical language. This knowledge is acquired, developed, and applied by the composer throughout the creative process. It does not result from the automated generation of musical content and is not delegated to an artificial intelligence system. The composer thus remains responsible for how the instrument’s characteristics are understood, utilized, and translated into their compositions.

7.1. Exploring the Instrument
Discovering an instrument is a personal process of observation, listening, experimentation, and understanding its characteristics. In particular, the composer explores its range, how it works, its technical possibilities, its timbres, its articulations, its playing techniques, its resonances, and the various ways it can be integrated into a composition.

This exploration may result from research, listening, practical trials, encounters with instrumentalists, or direct experimentation. The knowledge thus acquired forms part of the composer’s creative journey and influences decisions made later in the compositional process.

7.2. Learning
Learning the instrument and its musical language occurs gradually through study, practice, listening, experimentation, and the acquisition of technical and musical knowledge. The composer can draw on various educational resources—such as scores, recordings, discussions with performers, or observations of instrumental practice—to develop an understanding of the instrument.

This learning process then enables the composer to make more precise compositional decisions that are better suited to the instrument’s actual capabilities. It thus constitutes a journey of knowledge and personal development that directly contributes to the formation of the composer’s musical approach.

7.3. Inspiration
Inspiration related to the instrument stems from listening, experience, observation, musical practice, and the composer’s personal research. It may arise from the discovery of a sound, an instrumental gesture, a technical possibility, a combination of timbres, or a particular way of creating a dialogue between the instrument and other musical elements. The works, composers, performers, traditions, and repertoires studied may also contribute to this inspiration, while respecting existing works and their authors. Inspiration thus serves as a starting point that is then transformed through the composer’s personal work into a musical creation that is uniquely their own.

7.4. Writing for the Harp
Compositions for the harp are written with consideration for the instrument’s specific characteristics and the composer’s musical intentions. The composer determines the notes, registers, chords, movements, articulations, textures, playing techniques, and the various roles the harp can fulfill within the work. Compositional choices take into account the instrument’s specific capabilities and limitations so that the part is musically coherent and, when intended for performance, suited to the actual conditions of performance.

The possible use of a virtual instrument, a sound library, or a notation tool does not alter the origin of these choices: they are conceived and determined by the composer.

7.5. Expressive Possibilities
The composer retains control over the use of the instrument’s expressive possibilities. The composer determines how the instrument’s sonic and technical qualities are harnessed to serve musical expression: timbre, dynamics, register, resonance, articulation, density, movement, contrast, tension, or even dialogue with other instruments.

Exploring these possibilities can lead to the development of particular compositional techniques or the pursuit of specific sonic combinations. This approach relies on the composer’s listening and judgment, as the composer selects solutions that align with their artistic intent rather than delegating these choices to an automatic generation system.

7.6. Integration into Ensembles
The integration of the instrument within an ensemble is also determined by the composer. The composer chooses the function the instrument is to fulfill in the orchestration or arrangement, its relationship to the other sections, its place in the overall balance, the moments when it enters, its interactions with other instruments, and its development throughout the work.

This integration may serve melodic, harmonic, rhythmic, timbral, or expressive purposes. The composer thus takes into account the instrument’s specific characteristics while determining how it contributes to the ensemble’s overall identity.

7.7. Orchestration
Orchestration is the result of a personal creative and decision-making process. The composer determines how musical motifs are distributed among the various instruments, as well as timbral combinations, doubling, registers, density, and the relationships between the different parts. When a harp is integrated into an ensemble, its role and interaction with the other instruments are therefore determined based on the artistic intent and the structure of the work.

Orchestral libraries, virtual instruments, or software used to hear and evaluate this orchestration serve as tools for realization or sound preview; they do not themselves determine the orchestral distribution. All of these steps are part of the same process: the composer discovers, learns, experiments, imagines, writes, evaluates, and organizes the instrument’s possibilities in order to integrate them into his or her own musical language.

Technical tools can facilitate listening, notation, experimentation, or the production of a demo, but they cannot replace learning, critical listening, musical reflection, or the composer’s decisions. Knowledge of the instrument and its use in a composition thus remain the result of a human artistic journey and a gradual mastery of its possibilities.

8 • Composition Process

The composition process described in this charter is based on a series of primarily human steps, ranging from the emergence of inspiration to the completion of the recording. It can be represented according to the following general progression:

inspiration → musical idea → melody → harmony → structure → arrangement → orchestration → score → production → mixing → mastering

This sequence provides a general framework and should not be understood as a strictly linear or immutable process. Musical creation naturally involves backtracking, modifications, rewrites, experimentation, and successive adjustments. A decision made at a given stage may thus lead to revisiting a previous stage in order to enhance the coherence or expressiveness of the work.

8.1. Inspiration
The process can arise from inspiration, a sensation, an idea, an experience, something heard, musical research, an image, a concept, a sound, or any other impulse capable of triggering a creative process. This inspiration serves as a starting point and is not a pre-existing work intended to be reproduced. It is gradually interpreted and transformed by the composer to become a personal musical idea. Musical, cultural, and artistic influences may naturally play a role in this phase, but they are considered elements of context and reflection, distinct from the final creation.

8.2. Musical Idea
The inspiration is then transformed into one or more musical ideas. These may include a motif, a rhythm, a melodic cell, a harmonic progression, a timbre, an instrumental gesture, a texture, or a combination of several elements. The composer explores these initial ideas, plays them, notates them, records them, or develops them in order to assess their potential. Several possibilities may be experimented with before a direction is chosen. At this stage, as in subsequent ones, the decision to select, modify, or discard an idea is left to the composer’s judgment.

8.3. Melody
The musical idea can then give rise to a fully developed melody. The composer determines the pitches, intervals, rhythms, motifs, phrases, repetitions, variations, and developments that make up the melody. The melody can be built up gradually from an initial motif or undergo several successive revisions. In particular, the composer evaluates its character, coherence, expressiveness, relationship to the rhythm, and ability to integrate with the rest of the work. Any subsequent modification of the melody remains possible if it better serves the intended artistic goal.

8.4. Harmony
The melody and other musical motifs are then related to a harmonic structure determined by the composer. The composer chooses the chords, progressions, tensions, and resolutions, as well as any modulations or developments necessary for musical expression. Harmony can also precede or influence the melody: the process presented here does not, therefore, require that each step occur only once or in a strictly fixed order. Melody and harmony can evolve together during the compositional process, with each potentially leading to a change in the other until a coherent musical whole is achieved.

8.5. Structure
Once the main musical motifs have been established, the composer gradually builds the structure of the work. He determines the organization of the various sections, their sequence, their duration, their repetitions, their contrasts, their transitions, and their developments. The work may include an introduction, various developments, reprises, variations, breaks, or a conclusion, depending on the needs of its expression. The structure is not necessarily fully defined from the outset: it may emerge gradually from the musical motif and be reorganized as the work progresses. The composer remains responsible for all of these decisions.

8.6. Arrangement
Arrangement involves organizing and developing the various musical motifs to give them a more complete and coherent form. In particular, the composer determines how the different musical parts interact, the roles assigned to the various elements, the density of the music, the entries and exits, the accompaniments, the doubling, the variations, and the changes in texture. Arrangement thus allows a composition or musical idea to be transformed into a more detailed realization. The choices made at this stage remain under the composer’s control, and the composer can modify them until the form matches their intention.

8.7. Orchestration
Orchestration is the stage during which the composer determines how the various musical motifs are distributed among the instruments or the different voices of the ensemble. The composer selects the instruments, registers, timbres, doublings, combinations, densities, and respective functions of the different parts. Orchestration takes into account the specific characteristics of the instruments, their technical capabilities, their expressive possibilities, and their relationship to the ensemble. When a harp, for example, appears in the work, its role, its writing, and its integration into the ensemble are determined as part of this orchestral planning.

8.8. Score
When a work requires a score, the score serves as the written formalization of the musical decisions previously made. The composer includes—or has included—the information necessary for understanding, performing, and preserving the work: notes, rhythms, measures, articulations, dynamics, tempos, performance instructions, voice distribution, and other relevant instructions. The score can be created and edited using music notation software, which then serves as a tool for transcription and formatting. The musical content recorded in it remains determined by the composer. The score may also evolve during rehearsals, trials, or recordings when musical adjustments prove necessary.

8.9. Production
Production transforms musical choices and the score—if one exists—into a finished audio recording. This stage may include preparing sessions, recording performers, programming virtual instruments, using a MIDI keyboard, selecting sounds, editing takes, organizing tracks, creating demos, adding or modifying certain elements of the arrangement, and all operations necessary to construct the recorded version.

The digital tools used at this stage are under the composer’s control and serve to implement the decisions made in the previous stages. When the production process reveals a need for rewriting or adaptation, the composer may return to the composition, arrangement, or orchestration to improve the result.

8.10. Mixing
Mixing involves creating the sound balance of the work using the various recorded or produced elements. During this stage, the composer determines the relative levels, stereo positioning, depth, dynamics, equalization, processing, effects, spatial relationships, and the relationships between the various sound sources. Mixing is therefore not merely a technical operation: it also contributes to the artistic expression and perception of the work. Decisions are made based on the musical intent, the clarity of the various parts, the desired balance, and the intended sonic character.

8.11. Mastering
Mastering is the final stage in preparing an audio production. Its primary goals are to ensure the consistency of the final output, overall balance, dynamics, and level, as well as the file’s compatibility with the various intended uses and distribution formats. When carried out under the composer’s supervision, the composer retains responsibility for the artistic and technical choices that determine the final result. The processing applied at this stage is considered a means of finalization and not a new, independent source of creation. The composer evaluates the result of the mastering to verify that it remains consistent with the work’s intent and identity.

8.12. An Iterative Process
The sequence presented above describes a general logic, not a mandatory procedure in which each step must be definitively completed before the next one begins. Musical composition is an iterative process: a discovery made during production may lead to changes in the arrangement; an orchestration challenge may lead to rewriting a part; a rehearsal with a performer may reveal the need to adapt a score; mixing may bring to light a problem with structure or balance; and a final listen may lead to revisiting certain earlier steps. This feedback is an integral part of the creative process and does not call into question its human nature. On the contrary, it reflects a process of successive evaluation, exploration, and decision-making.

8.13. Review and Approval
At each of these stages, the composer retains responsibility for the artistic direction and approval of the results. The various versions produced during the process may be compared, corrected, retained, or discarded based on artistic and technical criteria determined by the composer. The tools used may perform certain technical operations automatically, but their operation should not be confused with an independent artistic contribution. The decision to retain, modify, or reject a result rests with the composer.

The process described in this charter is thus based on a continuous chain of human decisions: inspiration gives rise to an idea, the idea is developed musically, then organized, orchestrated, transcribed, produced, and finalized until the definitive work is achieved. Each stage may be subject to experimentation and revision, but the entire process remains under the composer’s direction. No artistic content generated by artificial intelligence is used to replace or determine these stages. The technologies employed in the process are tools for creation, production, recording, processing, or finalization; they do not constitute an autonomous source of composition or artistic decision-making.

9 • Composition and Score

The score is the written formalization of the work and serves to accurately convey the composer’s musical intentions to the performers and, where applicable, to those involved in the preparation or production of the work. It is not merely a graphical representation automatically generated from a sound output: it is the result of a process of notation, organization, verification, and revision carried out under the composer’s supervision.

When music notation software is used, it serves as a tool for entering, editing, formatting, and reproducing musical information. The content of the score, its structure, and the instructions it contains remain determined by the composer.

9.1. Musical Notation
Musical notation is created with the goal of representing as faithfully as possible the elements necessary for understanding and interpreting the work. It may include, in particular, pitches, rhythms, measures, tempos, dynamics, articulations, phrasing, character indications, changes in meter, instrumental indications, playing techniques, and other information necessary for the musical performance. The choice of information to include, its organization, and its prioritization are the composer’s responsibility. Notation may be developed gradually based on drafts, sketches, recordings, instrumental trials, or successive versions of the work.

9.2. Readability
Readability is an essential principle of score writing. A score must allow the performer to quickly and unambiguously identify the information necessary for the performance. The layout of the staves, the division of measures, dynamics and articulation markings, tempo changes, performance instructions, and the overall organization of the page are therefore carefully considered.

Page layout is not merely an aesthetic consideration: it directly contributes to the understanding of the music and the conditions under which it can be performed. In particular, the composer takes care to avoid unnecessarily ambiguous notation, contradictory instructions, or notations that might make the score difficult to read.

When multiple notational options are possible, the one that most clearly conveys the musical intention may be preferred. Readability is thus sought based on the instrument, the level of difficulty, the performance context, and the specific requirements of the work.

9.3. Precision
The precision of the notation aims to reduce ambiguities between the composer’s intention and the performer’s realization of it. The information necessary for the performance must be indicated clearly enough to allow for an understanding of the essential musical elements.

This may include, in particular, rhythms, pitches, fingering (when relevant), articulation, dynamics, phrasing, tempos, time signature changes, pedal or register markings, and various playing techniques.

However, precision does not mean that every aspect of the performance must necessarily be specified down to the smallest detail. Certain elements may be deliberately left to the performer’s discretion when such freedom is part of the artistic intent. The role of the score is therefore to distinguish between what must be precisely specified and what may remain open to interpretation. The composer retains responsibility for this distinction.

9.4. Instrumental Constraints
The composition takes into account the actual characteristics of the instruments for which the parts are intended. The composer considers their range, technical capabilities, registers, articulations, playing techniques, mechanical limitations, expressive possibilities, and practical performance conditions.

This consideration aims to produce a composition that is both musically relevant and technically feasible. In the case of the harp, special attention may be paid to the arrangement of the notes, playing possibilities, necessary adjustments for performance, registers, resonances, articulations, fingerings, and the constraints specific to the instrument.

The composition can be adapted to take these characteristics into account without compromising the original musical intent. When multiple solutions are possible, the composer seeks a balance between the desired expression, technical feasibility, and the actual conditions of performance.

Knowledge of instrumental constraints is therefore not merely a verification carried out after composition. It can come into play from the earliest stages of writing and directly influence choices regarding melody, harmony, arrangement, and orchestration. Trials, discussions with performers, or practical tests may lead to modifying a section to make it sound more natural, more expressive, or easier to perform.

9.5. Performability
The score is designed to be performable under musical and technical conditions consistent with the characteristics of the work. The composer ensures that the necessary information is sufficiently explicit to allow the performer to understand the function and intent of the various parts.

Technical difficulty may naturally be significant when it serves an artistic purpose, but it must be compatible with the instrument’s actual capabilities and the conditions under which the performance is to take place. Playability also involves taking into account the realities of the performer’s work.

A musical notation may be theoretically correct yet unnecessarily complex or unnatural to perform. Whenever possible, the composer therefore seeks a notation that allows the performer to focus their attention on musical expression rather than on resolving ambiguities or avoidable notational difficulties. Discussions with performers can help identify these situations and improve the score without compromising the composer’s artistic intent.

9.6. Revision
The score undergoes a verification and revision process before it is considered final. This revision may cover the musical content as well as the notation, the consistency of instructions, the layout, any transcription errors, and the feasibility of the arrangement for the instruments. Changes may result from a personal review, a rehearsal, an instrumental trial, feedback from performers, or a comparison with the corresponding recording or demo.

Revision may also lead to a reevaluation of previous musical choices. For example, a difficulty encountered during performance may lead to changes in articulation, rhythm, instrumental distribution, or performance instructions, or even to the rewriting of a passage when this better realizes the artistic intent. The score is thus considered a living document during the creation and preparation phase, until it is approved by the composer.

9.7. Final Approval of the Score
The final version of the score is approved by the composer after verifying its musical consistency, readability, accuracy, and suitability for the intended instrumental requirements and performance conditions. This approval constitutes a stage of human oversight in the process of creating and documenting the work.

The software used to produce or edit the score may facilitate certain technical operations, but it does not determine either its musical content or its final form. The score thus serves as a medium for transmission, a working document, and, where relevant, a record of the creative process. It must reflect the musical decisions actually made by the composer and provide performers with the information necessary to perform the work. Its development is based on a combination of creation, notation, verification, listening, experimentation, and revision, all of which are fully integrated into the artistic process described in this charter.

10 • Orchestration and Arrangements

Orchestration and arrangement are essential stages of the creative process, during which the composer determines how the various musical motifs are distributed, developed, and related to one another within an instrumental or vocal ensemble. These choices include, in particular, the selection of instruments, their range, their role, their articulation, their dynamics, their density, their interactions, and their evolution throughout the work.

Orchestration, therefore, is not merely a matter of assigning a melody to an instrument or distributing notes among several parts: it plays a direct role in shaping the timbre, texture, depth, contrast, and sonic identity of the work. Arrangements follow the same principle of artistic control. They allow a musical motif to be adapted, developed, or transformed according to the chosen ensemble, the performance context, and the intended effect.

The composer can thus modify the distribution of voices, add or remove elements, expand certain parts, create dialogues, emphasize certain musical functions, or gradually evolve the texture. These decisions are made based on the work itself and not through the automatic generation of musical proposals. Virtual instruments, orchestral libraries, and other tools used to listen to or produce a demo are technical means for implementing the composer’s choices.

10.1. Solo Instruments
When an instrument is used as a soloist, the composer determines its musical role, its motif, its range, its development, and its potential relationships with the other elements of the work. The composition may draw on the instrument’s unique characteristics to highlight its sonic personality, expressive capabilities, and technical possibilities.

The relationship between the soloist and the accompaniment is also designed to maintain the desired balance and allow the solo motif to fulfill its intended function. Composition for a solo instrument may also seek to exploit internal contrasts: registers, dynamics, articulations, density, timbre, or shifts in character. The composer chooses the techniques suited to his or her intent and may allow the instrument’s role to evolve over the course of the work. All of these choices are part of the composer’s musical conception and personal style.

10.2. Ensembles
For instrumental ensembles, the composer determines how the various parts are distributed among the instruments and their functions within the ensemble. Each instrument may assume a melodic, harmonic, rhythmic, contrapuntal, textural, or coloristic role, and these functions may evolve over the course of the work. The interactions between the various parts are designed to create balances, contrasts, dialogues, and developments consistent with the artistic intent.

Orchestration for an ensemble also takes into account the registers and acoustic characteristics of the instruments. The composer may choose to bring certain timbres closer together, create sharp contrasts, create a dialogue between different instrumental families, or gradually alter the ensemble’s density. The distribution of musical motifs is thus conceived as an active component of the composition rather than a mere step in transcription.

10.3. Orchestras
Orchestral composition requires a broader consideration of the distribution of musical motifs, the balance among instrument families and registers, and the development of the overall sound. In particular, the composer determines which instruments or sections carry the themes, countermelodies, harmonic elements, rhythmic reinforcements, or various textures. Doublings and combinations of timbres are chosen based on their musical function and the desired sound color.

Orchestration can also evolve depending on the structure of the work. A single musical idea may be introduced with a reduced instrumentation and then gradually developed, or, conversely, transition from a dense texture to a more sparse style of writing. The entries and exits of sections, changes in register, layering, and dynamic contrasts all contribute to the construction of the form. Each decision is made based on the intended musical role and the overall coherence of the work.

10.4. Choirs
When a choir is featured, the composer determines the distribution of voices, their function, their range, their interactions, and their relationship to other musical elements. The composition may take into account the different vocal ranges, the comprehensibility of the text (when present), the density of the chords, melodic movements, articulation, dynamics, and the possibilities for collective or individual expression.

The choir can be used to carry a melodic motif, as a harmonic element, as a mass of sound, as a response to an instrument, or as a component of a broader texture. The composer decides on the function assigned to it and how it evolves within the work. The specific constraints of vocal composition and the actual conditions of performance are taken into account in order to preserve both the artistic intent and the performability of the score.

10.5. Hybrid Ensembles
Hybrid ensembles combine several types of sound sources or ensembles, such as acoustic instruments, electronic instruments, virtual instruments, voices, recorded elements, or digital production devices. Their use is based on the same principles of human design as other forms of orchestration.

The composer determines the place, role, function, and interactions of each element within the work. In particular, a hybrid ensemble can be used to create contrasts between different sound families, to combine acoustic instruments with electronic textures, or to supplement traditional instrumentation with digitally produced sounds. The technologies used to produce these sounds remain merely means to an end. The decision to incorporate them, the way they are combined, their organization, and their musical function are determined by the composer.

10.6. Harp
The harp holds a special place in orchestration when it is incorporated into a work. Its use requires consideration of its unique characteristics, its range, its harmonic possibilities, its resonances, its playing techniques, its projection, and its technical limitations. The composer personally determines the function assigned to the harp, whether it be a solo, harmonic, melodic, rhythmic, textural, or coloristic role.

Composing for the harp can notably make use of resonances, arpeggios, chords, register shifts, contrasts in density, and the possibilities for layering with other instruments. However, the composer must distinguish between the theoretical possibility of a sound effect and its actual instrumental feasibility. When necessary, the score is reviewed and adapted according to the instrument’s limitations and performance conditions. In an orchestral or larger ensemble context, the harp is also integrated based on its relationship to other instruments.

The composer may seek out combinations of timbres, doubling, contrasts, or transitions between the harp and various instrumental families. The composer also determines when the harp should be brought to the forefront, integrated into the overall texture, or used as a color element. Its role is therefore not determined independently of the ensemble, but rather in accordance with the structure and overall intent of the work.

10.7. Consistency of Orchestration
The orchestration and arrangements must remain consistent with the composition, structure, and expressive intent of the work. The choice of an instrument or a combination of instruments is not made solely based on its availability or its sound in isolation, but rather on its contribution to the desired musical result.

In particular, the composer evaluates the complementarity of timbres, the balance between the different parts, the clarity of musical motifs, and the evolution of the texture throughout the work. This coherence may lead to changes in the orchestration after listening, rehearsal, or the production of a demo. An instrument may be replaced, a part may be redistributed, a doubling may be removed or added, and the density of a passage may be adjusted. These modifications are part of the normal creative process and reflect the evolving nature of orchestration.

10.8. Composer’s Control
All decisions regarding orchestration and arrangement remain under the composer’s control. Music notation software, DAWs, virtual instruments, orchestral libraries, synthesizers, and other tools may be used to experiment, listen, record, or produce results that reflect the choices made. However, they do not independently determine the instrumentation, the distribution of parts, the structure of the arrangement, or the musical function of the various parts.

When several possibilities are explored, the composer evaluates them and retains those that align with their artistic intent. The results can be corrected, modified, or discarded at any time. The final orchestration is therefore the result of a series of human decisions regarding instruments, voices, registers, timbres, functions, balances, and interactions. No generative artificial intelligence system is involved in determining or generating these choices in the process described in this charter.

11 • Music Production

Music production encompasses all the processes involved in transforming a composed, arranged, and orchestrated work into a complete audio production. It takes place after or in parallel with the various stages of composition and may include programming, the use of MIDI, the use of virtual instruments, the recording of performers or sound sources, editing, mixing, and mastering.

These processes are based on the musical and artistic decisions made by the composer and aim to translate those decisions into a coherent audio production. Production may also involve revisiting earlier stages when listening or production constraints reveal the need for a change. Production is therefore not a process independent of composition.

It builds on the choices made during the composition, arrangement, and orchestration phases. The composer may need to adapt a passage, modify the instrumentation, revise the articulation, change the timbre, or reorganize certain elements when he or she realizes that the resulting sound does not sufficiently match the original intention. These adjustments remain human decisions and are part of the normal creative and production process.

11.1. Solo Instruments
When a solo instrument is featured in a production, its part is realized in accordance with the previously defined compositional and orchestration choices. Depending on the context, the instrument may be played and recorded by a performer, reproduced using a virtual instrument, or integrated into a production that combines several methods.

The composer determines the musical content, the instrument’s role, its articulation, its range, its expression, and its place within the ensemble. When a virtual instrument is used to perform a solo part, it serves as a means of sonically reproducing a musical part conceived by the composer. The notes, rhythms, articulations, nuances, dynamics, and other musical parameters are determined or controlled by the composer. The use of a virtual instrument therefore does not mean that the instrument or the software composes the musical part.

11.2. MIDI
MIDI can be used as a means of transmitting, recording, and editing musical information. In particular, it allows users to record notes played on a keyboard or other compatible interface, modify their duration, position, velocity, or certain control parameters, and then transmit them to a virtual instrument or another compatible device.

Within the framework of the process described in this charter, MIDI is considered a format and a control protocol, not an independent source of creation. The MIDI information used in the works results from an interpretation, programming, or editing carried out under the composer’s control.

Using them can make it easier to experiment with and modify a musical part, but decisions regarding the musical content remain a human responsibility. MIDI editing can be used, for example, to correct an error, change a rhythm, adjust an articulation, move a note, modify a velocity, or adapt a part to an expressive intention. These operations constitute production and editing interventions under the composer’s control.

11.3. Virtual Instruments
Virtual instruments can be used to reproduce or generate the sounds needed to create a piece of music. In particular, they provide access to instrumental, orchestral, electronic, or synthetic sounds within a digital production environment. Their use is comparable to that of an instrument or a playback device: the composer determines which musical part should be played, by which instrument, in which register, and according to which instructions.

The parameters specific to the virtual instrument can also be adjusted to achieve the desired sound. This may include, in particular, the choice of articulation, register, dynamics, playing style, or timbre variation, when these parameters are available. These choices are made according to the composer’s artistic intent.

The use of a virtual instrument should not be confused with the use of an artificial intelligence-based music generation system. A virtual instrument used to perform a part specified by the composer is not considered the author of that part. The distinction lies in the fact that the musical content is conceived and controlled by the composer, while the virtual instrument serves as the technical means for performing it.

11.4. Recording
Recording allows for the capture of performances, instruments, voices, or various sound sources intended to form the final production. It may involve acoustic recordings, instrumental performances, vocals, electronic sources, or any other sound elements necessary for the work. The choice of recording conditions, which takes to keep, positions, levels, microphones, interfaces, any processing, and the various recorded versions is a matter for production decisions.

When multiple takes are recorded, comparing them and selecting the elements for the final version is done under human supervision. The recording may also reveal elements that require correction or a new interpretation. The composer may then decide to keep a take, modify it, replace it, or make a new recording. This ability to select and approve elements plays a direct role in the artistic control of the process.

11.5. Programming
Music programming involves, among other things, defining and organizing the information needed to create the parts produced in a digital environment. It may include MIDI programming, creating sequences, organizing events, automating parameters, controlling virtual instruments, and preparing the various production tracks. Programming is carried out according to the musical and expressive choices determined by the composer.

The composer can manually program the various sections, modify them incrementally, adjust their articulation, dynamics, or interpretation, and create variations designed to bring the digital realization closer to the musical intention. Programming is therefore not a stage during which an autonomous system determines the musical content; rather, it is a means of implementing decisions previously made or developed by the composer.

11.6. Editing
Editing includes operations used to correct, organize, clean up, adjust, or prepare the various recorded or programmed elements. This may include, in particular, editing takes, correcting errors, adjusting synchronization, modifying MIDI data, managing silences, preparing audio regions, and organizing the various tracks.

These operations can be performed using automated functions available in production software, but their use remains under the composer’s control. A technical function that allows an element to be moved, cut, aligned, corrected, or processed does not, in and of itself, constitute an independent creative contribution. The composer decides on the desired result, controls the changes made, and approves their inclusion in the final version.

11.7. Mixing
Mixing involves bringing together and balancing the various elements of the production to create a coherent soundscape. It includes decisions regarding levels, panning, equalization, dynamics, effects, reverb, spatialization, depth, and the relationships between the different sources. These choices can have both a technical and an artistic dimension. In particular, the composer determines which elements should be brought to the forefront, which should remain in the background, how the different parts should interact, and what overall impression the whole should produce. Mixing therefore contributes to the final expression of the work and remains subject to the artistic intent defined during the creative process.

11.8. Mastering
Mastering is the final stage in the processing and preparation of a sound production. In particular, it establishes the final sound, ensures overall consistency, and prepares the files for various uses or distribution formats. These operations may involve spectral balance, dynamics, overall level, technical compatibility, and consistency among multiple works when they are intended to be presented together.

When mastering is carried out under the composer’s supervision, decisions regarding the final sound are made and approved by the composer. Mastering tools can automatically apply certain mathematical or technical operations, but their use does not mean that they determine the artistic identity of the work. The composer remains responsible for the final result and can compare different versions, modify the processing, or return to the mixing stage if the result does not match the intended outcome.

11.9. Production Oversight and Approval
At each stage of production, the composer retains a role in decision-making, oversight, and approval. Digital tools may automate certain technical operations, but they do not thereby constitute independent authors or contributors to the work. The composer determines what should be recorded, programmed, edited, processed, retained, or deleted, and evaluates the results against the musical intent.

The production process may also be iterative. Listening may reveal that an instrument is too prominent, that an articulation needs to be modified, that a part needs to be re-recorded, or that an arrangement needs to be adapted. The composer can then return to a previous stage, modify the relevant motif, and resume the process. This capacity for ongoing revision is a standard feature of music production.

Ultimately, the music production described in this charter relies on the use of technical tools designed to create, record, program, edit, and finalize human musical decisions. MIDI, virtual instruments, production software, recording tools, editing functions, mixing processes, and mastering tools are used as means under the composer’s control. None of these tools constitutes, in the process described here, an autonomous source of composition or artistic generation by artificial intelligence.

12 • Music for Visual Media

For the purposes of this charter, “music for visual media” refers to any musical composition intended to accompany, support, complement, or enrich visual, audiovisual, interactive, or narrative content. It may be composed, in particular, for feature films, short films, series, documentaries, video games, digital content, stage performances, narrative works, or any other medium in which music has a special relationship with an image, an action, a situation, or a dramatic progression. The fact that the music is intended for an external medium does not alter the fundamental creative principles established by this charter: it remains conceived and developed by the composer, through a human process and under the composer’s artistic control.

12.1. The Relationship Between Music and Images
When music is composed to accompany a visual image, the composer takes into account the visual and narrative elements associated with it. These may include movements, characters, locations, situations, camera cuts, events, dialogue, emotions, dramatic intentions, or even the overall progression of a scene. These elements provide information to which the composer responds through musical choices.

They can influence the character, tempo, instrumentation, density, dynamics, structure, or duration of the music, without automatically determining its content.

Music can thus serve various functions: accompanying an action, reinforcing an emotion, creating an atmosphere, highlighting a transition, introducing tension, creating a contrast with the visuals, establishing continuity between scenes, or contributing to the identity of a character, a location, or a world.

The choice of musical function is up to the composer and depends on their interpretation of the medium and the desired artistic intent. A single scene may thus give rise to several different musical proposals before a solution is selected.

12.2. Narrative and Dramaturgy
Music can also be viewed as an element that contributes to the narrative. The composer may use themes, motifs, timbres, instruments, harmonic progressions, or recurring musical structures to accompany the development of a story or a world. Musical elements can be associated with characters, situations, places, or ideas and evolve over the course of the narrative to reflect their transformation. This approach involves reflecting on the relationship between music and the narra The composer determines when a theme appears, transforms, disappears, or returns, as well as any contrasts or parallels between the music and the narrative. These choices stem from a human analysis of the narrative context and the composer’s own artistic intent. No artificial intelligence system is used to automatically analyze the narrative in order to generate the musical elements for the work.

12.3. Atmospheres and Sound Identity
Creating atmospheres is another important aspect of film music. The composer may seek a particular sound color, sensation, tension, sense of space, or character to complement the visual or narrative world. Choices regarding instrumentation, timbre, harmony, register, dynamics, texture, and production are then determined based on the desired atmosphere.

A sonic identity can also be built through the repetition or evolution of certain elements. A specific instrumentation, a family of timbres, a playing technique, or a harmonic process can become recurring characteristics of a project. The composer retains control over these choices and determines how they are introduced, developed, and transformed throughout the work or audiovisual project.

12.4. Synchronization
Synchronization is a specific constraint of film scoring. When certain events must correspond precisely to musical elements, the composer may adapt the tempo, structure, transitions, accents, silences, harmonic changes, instrumental entries, or developments in order to meet the necessary synchronization points. This constraint may lead to composing music based on precise temporal markers or modifying an existing composition to adapt it to a sequence.

Composers can also use production tools that allow them to display the music and visual elements simultaneously, set time markers, or verify the accuracy of the synchronization. These tools facilitate the technical work but do not make musical decisions on the composer’s behalf.

12.5. Interactive Music and Video Games
In the case of a video game or other interactive environment, music can be designed to function according to various states or situations. The composer can create different pieces, variations, layers, transitions, or musical elements intended to be triggered or combined based on the player’s actions, the progression of the scene, or events defined by the project. Interactivity may therefore require a specific approach to musical structure.

The composer may include multiple entry, exit, or transition points to allow the music to adapt to the unfolding of the experience. The various musical motifs, however, remain entirely the composer’s creation. The computer systems used to trigger, synchronize, or subsequently combine these elements are technical means of integration and are not considered sources of musical creation.

12.6. Adapting to Media Constraints
Music for visual media may be subject to specific constraints regarding duration, format, synchronization, narrative, or distribution. The composer may need to create multiple versions of the same piece of music, adapt an arrangement, modify a structure, produce a shorter or longer version, or prepare different elements for distinct purposes.

These adaptations are not independent creations produced automatically, but rather variations resulting from decisions made by the composer based on the project’s needs. The constraints of the medium may thus lead to repeating certain steps in the process of composition, arrangement, orchestration, or production. This potential for modification and adaptation is consistent with the iterative nature of the creative process already defined in this charter.

12.7. Artistic Control and the Human Process
Music for film remains subject to the same fundamental principles as the other works covered by this charter. The visuals, screenplay, narrative, acting, dramatic cues, or synchronization constraints may serve as contextual elements and guide the creative process, but they do not themselves generate the musical content. The composer interprets these elements and personally determines the appropriate musical response. Compositions, melodies, harmonies, structures, arrangements, orchestrations, scores, and productions intended for film music are thus created through the same human process as other creative works.

Production software, synchronization tools, DAWs, virtual instruments, notation systems, and other technical resources may be used to create and finalize the work, but no artistic contributions generated by artificial intelligence are used in the process described in this charter. Music for film therefore constitutes a specific application of the creative process and not an exception to its principles. The medium influences the constraints and can inspire creation; the composer remains responsible for the musical response, its composition, orchestration, production, and final approval. This distinction helps preserve both the reality of the work of composing for film and transparency regarding the human origin of the works.

13 • Influences, Inspirations, and Tributes

Every musical creation is part of an artistic, cultural, and historical context. Throughout their career, composers may be exposed to numerous works, aesthetics, techniques, traditions, interpretations, and musical movements. These elements can fuel their thinking, develop their musical culture, guide certain areas of exploration, or spark inspiration. Recognizing these influences does not, however, mean that a new work constitutes a reproduction of a previous work. This charter therefore explicitly distinguishes between artistic influence, inspiration, homage, and the reproduction of an existing work.

13.1. Musical Influences
An influence refers to the impact that a work, a composer, a performer, a movement, an era, an aesthetic, or a musical practice can have on the way a composer thinks about or develops their own music. This influence may generally pertain to a harmonic approach, instrumentation, texture, form, compositional technique, use of rhythm, orchestral conception, or exploration of sound.

Being influenced by a work does not necessarily mean incorporating an identifiable element from that work. An influence can be diffuse, indirect, or result from the accumulation of numerous musical experiences. It can contribute to the development of the composer’s personal musical language without any specific element of the source work being reproduced in the final composition. The composer can thus acknowledge certain influences in his or her career while still considering the resulting work to be a distinct creation. The presence of an influence stems from the artistic context in which a work was conceived and does not, in and of itself, call into question its personal character.

13.2. Inspiration
Inspiration is the starting point or one of the possible triggers of the creative process. It can come from listening to a piece of music, a personal experience, an image, a place, an emotion, an instrumental discovery, a book, a narrative situation, or any other element capable of sparking a musical idea.

Inspiration is not reproduction. A work may be inspired by an atmosphere, a sensation, an artistic approach, or a general idea, while still resulting in an entirely new musical creation. The composer transforms what inspired them through their own musical language and their own melodic, harmonic, structural, orchestral, and expressive choices. It is therefore important to distinguish between the element that triggers creative thought and the musical content that is actually created. Inspiration can contribute to the origin of a work without constituting a part of that work.

13.3. Reference and Aesthetics
A work may also deliberately reference a particular aesthetic, era, genre, or musical tradition. The composer may seek a specific sound, employ certain instrumental characteristics, or consciously align with a compositional tradition. These choices can help situate a work within an identifiable artistic context.

A general aesthetic reference does not, in and of itself, constitute a reproduction of a specific work. The composer may draw on certain conventions or general characteristics of a musical language while developing a unique texture. The approach, then, involves using a musical vocabulary or artistic context as a creative framework rather than reproducing the specific content of an existing work.

13.4. Tribute
A tribute is a deliberate effort to acknowledge, evoke, or celebrate a work, a composer, a performer, a tradition, or a particular influence. It may take the form of a stylistic reference, an instrumental choice, an evocation, a compositional technique, or a symbolic element.

An homage should not be confused with a reproduction. When an homage is based on a previous work, the composer should, as a matter of principle, develop a new creation that is identifiable as such. When the homage intentionally includes a more specific or recognizable reference, its nature and context may be transparently documented when relevant.

13.5. Personal Creation and Transformation
Personal creation involves the transformation and development of ideas. An element that has piqued the composer’s interest may be studied, analyzed, or serve as a starting point for research, but the composer then constructs his or her own work based on musical decisions. In particular, the composer determines the melodies, harmonies, structures, arrangements, orchestrations, timbres, and production choices that make up the final result.

This transformation can result in a work that is very different from its starting point. It can also retain certain general characteristics of an aesthetic or tradition while developing distinct musical content. Personal creation thus relies on the composer’s active involvement and on the series of successive choices that give the work its form and identity.

13.6. The Difference Between Influence and Reproduction
The fundamental distinction can be summarized as follows: being influenced by a work means that it may have contributed to the composer’s context, thought process, or artistic direction; reproducing a work means incorporating all or part of its content in a manner close enough that this incorporation itself constitutes an identifiable element of the new work.

An influence may relate to a general aesthetic, a technique, an era, a genre, an instrumental timbre, or a musical approach. A reproduction, by contrast, concerns the specific content of a prior work and may, in particular, involve the use of an identifiable musical motif. These two situations should therefore not be equated.

The mere fact that a new work may evoke another work is not, in and of itself, sufficient to establish that it constitutes a reproduction of that work. The analysis must take into account the nature of the resemblance, its degree of precision, whether it is intentional or not, the function of the element in question, and the creative work carried out around it. This charter does not purport to replace a legal analysis when a copyright issue arises, but clearly establishes the artistic principle that composers seek to develop their own creations rather than reproduce those of others.

13.7. Absence of Intentional Reproduction
Within the framework of the process described in this charter, the composer does not seek to intentionally reproduce an existing work by presenting it as a personal creation. The works studied, listened to, or likely to have influenced the composer’s artistic journey constitute cultural or artistic references and are not used as sources intended to be copied or reproduced.

When pre-existing elements are intentionally used in a context requiring authorization, a license, attribution, or any other appropriate procedure, this situation is treated separately and must be identified accordingly. This statement concerns the general principle of creation: new works are conceived as personal creations and are not based on the undeclared reproduction of the musical content of an existing work.

13.8. Transparency Regarding Influences
When it serves an artistic or documentary purpose, the composer may identify certain major influences, references, or intentions to pay homage associated with a work. This approach makes it possible to clearly distinguish the context in which the work was created from its own musical content.

Transparency regarding influences does not constitute an acknowledgment of any kind of reproduction. On the contrary, it allows for documenting the artistic journey surrounding the creation and demonstrates how musical references can contribute to a personal exploration. The goal is to honestly present the creative process without confusing the existence of an influence with a reproduction of a work.

Thus, a work can be influenced without being reproduced, inspired without being copied, and pay homage without losing its personal character. The composer acknowledges that every creation is part of a musical and cultural history, while affirming his or her responsibility for transforming these influences into a new work. This charter therefore establishes a clear distinction between the artistic context that inspired the creation and the content actually composed, written, arranged, orchestrated, and produced by its author.

14 • Originality and Artistic Integrity

Originality and artistic integrity are fundamental principles of the creative process described in this charter. The composer commits to developing works that result from his or her own choices, research, musical experience, and artistic intent. Originality is understood here as the desire to build a personal musical identity and to produce works that are not based on covert reproduction or the presentation as one’s own of a creation belonging to another.

This requirement does not mean that a work must be completely detached from any musical influence, reference, or tradition. Every creation exists within an artistic context and may share characteristics with other works, particularly when they belong to the same aesthetic, genre, or tradition. Artistic integrity consists precisely in recognizing this reality while maintaining a personal approach that is transparent and respectful of previous works.

14.1. Originality
The composer seeks to personally create and develop the elements that constitute the identity of his or her works. Melodies, harmonies, structures, arrangements, orchestrations, instrumental choices, textures, developments, and production decisions are developed through his or her own creative process. The various stages may draw on existing musical knowledge, proven techniques, or conventions specific to certain genres, but their combination and development result from personal decisions.

Originality is therefore viewed as an approach rather than an absolute assertion that no comparable elements exist elsewhere. The composer obviously cannot control all existing works or guarantee that no coincidental similarities will arise. However, the composer commits to not intentionally seeking to reproduce an existing work under the guise of a new creation and to exercising reasonable diligence regarding the elements incorporated into their own work.

14.2. Musical Identity
Musical identity refers to the set of characteristics that make it possible to recognize and distinguish a work or a body of works by a composer. It may result from choices regarding melody, harmony, rhythm, structure, instrumentation, orchestration, expression, or timbre, as well as from the particular way in which these elements are combined.

This identity is built gradually through experience, research, and practice. It is not necessarily defined in advance and may evolve over the course of the composer’s artistic career. This charter nevertheless affirms the commitment to preserve this identity against any substitution by automatically generated content or by the deliberate imitation of another creator. The technical tools used in the process are intended to serve this identity and not to determine it in place of the composer.

14.3. Sources of Inspiration
Sources of inspiration can include musical works, composers, performers, traditions, artistic movements, personal experiences, images, texts, landscapes, discoveries related to instruments, or various forms of research. It can arise at any stage of the creative process and help guide musical exploration.

However, inspiration serves as a starting point or contextual element, not as implicit permission to reproduce the content of an existing work. The composer seeks to transform the elements that inspire them into a personal creation by developing their own motifs and making their own choices. Influences and sources of inspiration can thus be acknowledged without being equated with an appropriation of the content of a previous work.

Where appropriate, the composer may also retain or disclose information that documents certain particularly significant influences. This transparency is intended to make the artistic journey more understandable and should not be interpreted as an acknowledgment of any form of reproduction.

14.4. Possible Citations
When an element from a previous work is intentionally cited or incorporated into a new creation, its nature must be distinguished from the original motif composed by the composer. A quotation may serve a specific artistic purpose, particularly as part of a tribute, a reference, a narrative device, or a dialogue with a previous work.

This charter therefore does not consider any intentional inclusion of a pre-existing element to be necessarily incompatible with a personal artistic approach. However, it requires that such instances be honestly identified and handled in accordance with the rights and conditions applicable to the work in question. When authorization, a license, attribution, or other formalities are required, these must be obtained and complied with prior to the use of the element in question.

Any quotations must therefore remain distinct from the motif presented as deriving directly from the composer’s own work. This distinction helps maintain the transparency of the creative process and avoid any confusion between a deliberate reference and an original composition.

14.5. Arrangements
An arrangement is a transformation or reorganization of an existing musical motif or a previously composed motif. When working on their own compositions, composers are free to create different arrangements in order to adapt a work to a specific ensemble, instrument, production context, or particular intent.

When an arrangement involves a work belonging to another author, the composer clearly distinguishes the work of arrangement from the creation of the original work. The composer does not present motifs belonging to the original author as a personal composition. The arrangement may constitute a significant and personal creative work, but this creativity does not necessarily negate the rights attached to the pre-existing work.

With regard to their own works, composers may, on the contrary, freely reorchestrate, reduce, expand, transcribe, or transform their motifs, subject to any rights granted to third parties who participated in the creation. These different versions are considered variations of the artistic work controlled by the composer.

14.6. Adaptations
An adaptation may involve modifying a work or a motif to suit a new context, a new ensemble, a new medium, or a new use. This may include, for example, an adaptation for another instrument, another ensemble, a version intended for a film, a version intended for a video game, a reduction, an extension, or a modification of the structure.

When the adaptation involves the composer’s own work, it is part of the normal process of developing and transforming the composer’s work. The composer may reuse their own motifs, modify them, and arrange them differently to meet the requirements of the new context. When an adaptation involves a third party’s work, the pre-existing nature of that work must be acknowledged, and the applicable legal or contractual conditions must be respected.

An adaptation should therefore not be confused with a new, entirely independent composition. It may involve considerable creative work while retaining essential elements of the original work. Transparency regarding the nature of the process allows for a clear distinction between original creation, arrangement, transcription, and adaptation.

14.7. Artistic Integrity
Artistic integrity requires that the composer honestly disclose the origin and nature of their work. They do not claim as entirely original content that they know has been taken from a third party, nor do they intentionally conceal substantial use of a pre-existing motif when such information is relevant. Similarly, they distinguish their own contributions from those that may have been made by performers, arrangers, sound engineers, or other human collaborators.

This requirement also applies to how technical tools are presented. The use of notation software, a DAW, a virtual instrument, or an audio processing tool does not make these tools the authors of the work. The charter thus clearly distinguishes between the technical means used to create the work and the artistic decisions that determine its content.

14.8. General Commitment
The composer commits to maintaining an approach based on personal creation, musical research, acknowledgment of influences, respect for existing works, and transparency regarding any use of pre-existing motifs. Unintentional similarities, genre conventions, and elements belonging to the common musical language are not automatically considered reproduction.

The purpose of this charter is not to artificially isolate the creative process from all external influences, but to document an honest artistic approach: to draw inspiration without reproducing, to learn without copying, to reference without concealing, to arrange without appropriating, and to adapt without erasing the origin of pre-existing motifs. Artistic integrity thus rests on the consistency between what the composer actually creates, the manner in which they create it, and the way in which they present this creation.

This section should be understood as a commitment to method and artistic transparency. It does not constitute a claim that any work is necessarily free from any resemblance to a prior creation, nor is it a legal analysis of the ownership of rights to a particular work. It establishes the principle that the composer personally makes the decisive choices regarding his or her creation, respects pre-existing works and contributions, and seeks to preserve the identity and integrity of his or her own creations.

15 • Collaboration with Musicians

As of the date of this charter, the works in question are produced without direct collaboration with external musicians, performers, singers, harpists, ensembles, orchestras, or sound engineers. The process of creation, composition, orchestration, production, and finalization is currently carried out by the composer using the tools and technical resources at his disposal. This section nevertheless defines the principles that would govern any future collaborations, without prejudging their existence, nature, or frequency.

The current absence of collaboration does not mean that the composer’s work is conceived independently of any knowledge of musical performance. The possibilities and limitations specific to instruments and voices can be explored through learning, listening, analyzing scores, observing performances, and experimentation. This approach allows the composer to take into account the realities of performance while retaining control over his compositional and orchestration choices.

15.1. Performers
In the event that performers are subsequently associated with a work, their role would be distinct from that of the composer. The performer’s role would be to bring a written or defined part of the work to life musically, contributing their expertise, sensitivity, experience, and expressive qualities. This contribution could enrich the musical performance without altering the distinction between the work of composition and the work of performance.

The composer may take into account the performer’s suggestions and observations when they serve to improve the feasibility, expression, or quality of the performance. Discussions with a musician may, in particular, lead to revisions of articulation, fingering, phrasing, register, or performance markings. When such discussions result in a substantial modification of the musical content, the nature of each party’s contribution must remain clearly identifiable.

15.2. Singers
In the case of a collaboration with one or more singers, they may perform the vocal parts specified in the composition. The composer would determine the musical context, structure, melodies, harmonies, and general intentions of the vocal part, while the singer would contribute their interpretation, technique, and expressive qualities.

The specific characteristics of the voice may require adapting certain parts to account for the performer’s range, breathing, articulation, diction, or expressive capabilities. These adaptations would be made through artistic dialogue when necessary, while maintaining a clear distinction between compositional choices and their interpretation.

15.3. Harpists
Collaborating with a harpist could provide a direct way to assess the feasibility and expressiveness of a composition written for the harp. In particular, the harpist could contribute their expertise regarding the instrument’s technical capabilities, fingerings, playing constraints, articulation, resonance, necessary adjustments, and solutions to make a part more natural to perform.

These discussions could lead to modifications or refinements to a score. However, drawing on a harpist’s expertise would not mean that the harpist would automatically be considered the author of the composition. The harpist’s involvement would be acknowledged according to the actual nature of their contribution. When their contribution relates to performance or instrumental advice, it would be distinguished from the composition; when a substantial creative contribution is actually made to the composition, it would be appropriately identified.

15.4. Ensembles
Collaborating with an instrumental or vocal ensemble could allow the composer to test the score in a real-world setting of collective performance. Rehearsals might reveal issues related to balance, coordination, breathing, placement, register, or readability that would not necessarily be apparent in an entirely digital production.

The composer could then modify certain parts, instructions, or voice parts to improve the work’s execution. These modifications would be incorporated into the revision process and would remain under the composer’s control when they pertain to compositional, arranging, or orchestration decisions. The performers’ own contributions, meanwhile, would remain distinct from those of the composer.

15.5. Orchestras
In the case of a collaboration with an orchestra, the preceding principles would apply on a larger scale. Rehearsals and discussions with instrumentalists, conductors, and artistic directors could provide valuable insights into the feasibility of the orchestration, the balance among the sections, articulation possibilities, and the actual performance conditions.

The composer could use these observations to improve the score and the orchestration. Such a collaboration would not call into question the origin of the composition: musical decisions would continue to be attributed according to the actual contributions made by each participant. The collective performance of a work would not transform the performers into the authors of the composition, while a specific and substantial creative contribution should be recognized as such.

15.6. Sound Engineers
You may work with a sound engineer during recording, editing, mixing, or mastering. The sound engineer may contribute technical expertise regarding sound capture, acoustics, microphone placement, editing, source processing, sound balance, dynamics, or preparation of the final mix.

The technical role of a sound engineer must be distinguished from compositional decisions. While the composer defines the musical content, arrangement, orchestration, and artistic intentions, and the engineer technically implements or optimizes these decisions, the two contributions are of a different nature. Technical collaboration can therefore significantly enhance the sound quality of a work without constituting participation in its composition.

15.7. Respect for Contributions
Any future collaboration will be based on respect for the work, expertise, and contribution of each participant. The composer agrees not to claim credit for a contribution that was actually made by another participant and to distinguish, where relevant, between composition, arrangement, performance, production, sound engineering, and other forms of participation.

Conversely, the fact that a musician performs, advises, or participates in the creation of a work does not automatically mean that he or she becomes a co-author. The exact nature of each contribution must be assessed based on the work actually performed. Participation in performance, execution, or technical production should not be confused with a creative contribution to the composition.

15.8. Current Situation
As of the date of this charter’s drafting, no collaboration of this nature is currently incorporated into the creative process described here. The works are conceived, written, arranged, orchestrated, and produced without the direct involvement of external performers, singers, harpists, ensembles, orchestras, or sound engineers.

This situation may change in the future if artistic conditions or production needs warrant it. Any evolution of the process would not call into question the fundamental principles of this charter: external contributions would be identified according to their actual nature, artistic responsibilities would be clearly distinguished, and any collaborations would be carried out in a transparent manner that respects the individuals involved.

This section therefore establishes a clear distinction between the process currently in use—which does not involve external collaboration—and the procedures that may govern future collaborations. This distinction allows us to accurately document the current situation without precluding the possibility of changes in our artistic work.

Originality and artistic integrity are fundamental principles of the creative process described in this charter. The composer commits to developing works that result from his or her own choices, research, musical experience, and artistic intent. Originality is understood here as the desire to build a personal musical identity and to produce works that are not based on covert reproduction or the presentation as one’s own of a creation belonging to another.

This requirement does not mean that a work must be completely detached from any musical influence, reference, or tradition. Every creation exists within an artistic context and may share characteristics with other works, particularly when they belong to the same aesthetic, genre, or tradition. Artistic integrity consists precisely in recognizing this reality while maintaining a personal approach that is transparent and respectful of previous works.

16 • Quality Control

Before a work is considered complete, it undergoes a review and validation process designed to verify its musical coherence, compositional quality, instrumental feasibility, orchestral balance, and the quality of its sound production. This review constitutes the final stage of verifying the work completed and may, when necessary, lead to revisiting certain earlier stages of the composition or production process.

Quality control should not be understood as a mere automated technical check. It relies primarily on the composer’s listening, reading, analysis, comparison, experimentation, and judgment. Software tools can facilitate certain checks or help identify technical issues, but the decision to consider a work sufficiently complete remains a human and artistic one.

16.1. Musical Coherence
Musical coherence is the first level of review. The composer examines the work as a whole to determine whether the various elements—melody, harmony, rhythm, structure, instrumentation, orchestration, arrangement, and production—function in a sufficiently coherent manner in light of the artistic intent.

This review focuses in particular on the relationships between the different sections, the intended continuity or contrasts, the development of musical motifs, the logic of transitions, and the overall balance of the work. A work may intentionally include breaks, tensions, or significant changes; these are considered artistic choices when they align with the intended purpose.

The review therefore involves distinguishing between an intentional break and an unintentional inconsistency. When an element appears not to fulfill its function properly, the composer may decide to modify it, develop it further, remove it, or revert to an earlier stage of the composition.

16.2. Quality of Composition
The quality of the writing is assessed by reading the score and, when possible, by listening to a performance of the piece. In particular, the composer checks the accuracy of the notes and rhythms, the consistency of the markings, articulations, dynamics, phrasing, tempos, time signature changes, and other information necessary for understanding the work.

This review also examines the consistency among the various instrumental and vocal parts. Doublings, movements, registers, harmonic relationships, and contrapuntal elements are examined to detect any errors or contradictions. Necessary corrections are made before the final version is approved.

The quality of the composition also includes the quality of the notation. A score may be musically correct yet difficult to read or unnecessarily ambiguous. The composer therefore verifies that the written representation effectively conveys the intentions necessary for the performance.

16.3. Playability and Instrumental Feasibility
When a work is intended to be performed by instruments or voices, its playability is an essential part of the final review. The composer verifies that the various parts correspond to the technical and physical capabilities of the instruments in question and that the instructions given in the score can be reasonably carried out.

This verification may specifically concern ranges, registers, movements, articulations, necessary changes, transitions, breathing, fingerings, and the specific constraints of each instrument. For the harp, particular attention may be paid to playing possibilities, constraints related to position changes, resonances, registers, and the feasibility of various note combinations.

When the feasibility of a passage is uncertain, the composer may conduct an additional review, seek an alternative compositional solution, or modify the passage in question. A technical difficulty is not necessarily considered a flaw when it is intentional and compatible with the performer’s capabilities; the goal is to distinguish between an intended artistic challenge and a difficulty resulting from an error or inadequate notation.

16.4. Orchestral Balance
Orchestral balance is checked to ensure that the various parts fulfill their roles properly within the ensemble. In particular, the composer examines the relationships in volume, register, density, and timbre among the different instrumental or vocal families.

This review helps determine whether a melody is sufficiently audible, whether an accompaniment remains in the desired position, whether certain voices are overly dominant, or whether certain essential elements are masked by the overall texture. It may also address the balance between solo instruments, ensembles, orchestras, choirs, and electronic or virtual elements when they are combined.

The desired balance, however, depends on the artistic intent. An intentionally dense orchestration—one that appears unbalanced or is characterized by extreme contrasts—may be an aesthetic choice. Quality control therefore aims above all to verify that the resulting work corresponds to the composer’s intent.

16.5. Sound Quality
Sound quality is evaluated based on all elements comprising the production. In particular, the composer checks for the absence of obvious technical defects, unwanted distortion, unwanted noise, dropouts, synchronization issues, artifacts, or anomalies that could impair the listening experience.

The evaluation may be conducted on different playback systems to verify that the result maintains sufficient consistency across various environments. When relevant, the composer may also compare different versions or processing options to determine which best aligns with the artistic intent.

Sound quality, however, is not synonymous with a systematic pursuit of technical perfection. Certain choices regarding texture, saturation, noise, dynamics, or processing may be intentional. The evaluation therefore involves distinguishing between desired characteristics and unwanted defects.

16.6. Mixing
The mix undergoes a specific review before the work is finalized. The composer checks the relative levels, panning, depth, space, frequencies, dynamics, effects, and the relationship between the various sources.

The goal is to ensure that the mix allows the work to retain its clarity and expressiveness. Important elements must be audible under the intended conditions, while secondary elements must fulfill their assigned functions. The mix is also evaluated in terms of the work’s structure and progression to ensure that changes in density and intensity are accurately conveyed.

When the mix does not match the original intent, the composer can modify the processing, levels, or organization of the tracks. The composer may also revisit the arrangement or orchestration when the problem cannot be resolved solely through the mix.

16.7. Mastering
Mastering undergoes a final check before the final file is approved. In particular, the composer reviews the overall level, dynamics, spectral balance, consistency of the sound, and the file’s suitability for the target format.

Mastering must not unintentionally alter the artistic choices made during the mixing process. If a final processing step excessively alters the desired dynamics, depth, timbres, or contrasts, a new version may be prepared. This allows the composer to return to the mix and adjust the production before proceeding to a new finalization.

When multiple works are intended to be presented together, an additional check may be performed to ensure overall consistency in their levels, timbres, and dynamics, without eliminating the artistic differences that were intentionally sought.

16.8. Conformity with the Original Intention
The final step in quality control involves comparing the final result with the intention that guided the creation. The composer verifies whether the work effectively conveys the character, atmosphere, structure, energy, timbre, or message that were sought at the beginning of the process.

This comparison does not mean that the work must remain identical to the initial idea. The compositional process is dynamic and can lead to significant discoveries or transformations. The original intent itself may be refined or modified during the course of the work. The final review therefore consists of verifying the consistency between the work as it ultimately exists and the artistic intent actually adopted by the composer at the end of the process.

A work can thus be considered successful even if it has strayed considerably from its initial sketch, provided that the final result corresponds to a consciously chosen and validated artistic intention.

16.9. Final Approval
After completing all these checks, the composer decides whether the work is sufficiently developed to be considered finished. This approval may occur immediately or after several additional cycles of revision and listening. There is not necessarily a fixed number of revisions: the amount of work required depends on the nature, complexity, and objectives of each work.

Final approval is an act of artistic decision-making. It signifies that the composer considers the main elements of composition, writing, orchestration, production, and sound engineering to have reached a satisfactory level in relation to the intended goal. If a significant weakness is identified, the work may remain a work in progress until a solution is found.

Quality control is thus based on a comprehensive approach: musical coherence, quality of composition, playability, orchestral balance, sound quality, mixing, mastering, and conformity with the artistic intent. These various criteria are not applied mechanically, but are evaluated by the composer based on the nature of the work. The final decision remains a human, conscious choice under the composer’s control.

17 • Documentation and Traceability

The purpose of documentation and traceability is to preserve an identifiable record of the creative process behind the works. They make it possible, when necessary, to trace the various stages of the work, from the initial ideas or sketches to the final version. This documentation serves as a means of making the creative process more transparent and preserving elements that help explain how the work was composed, written, arranged, orchestrated, and produced.

Traceability does not mean that every action, every listening session, or every minor modification must necessarily be recorded in exhaustive detail. Since the creative process is evolving and sometimes experimental, certain explorations may be abandoned, replaced, or carried out informally. Rather, the goal is to preserve, when relevant, elements that are significant enough to establish continuity between the various stages of the work and the version ultimately selected.

17.1. Successive Versions
Where appropriate, different versions of a work may be preserved throughout its development. These may include sketches, initial structures, intermediate versions, revisions to the arrangement, orchestral versions, changes to the score, or different stages of production.

Preserving multiple versions demonstrates that the work is the result of a gradual process of exploration, modification, and selection. It can also help illustrate the evolution of a musical idea, an orchestration, or a production as the work progresses. An earlier version may thus reflect a stage of exploration without necessarily being intended for publication or performance.

When multiple versions are preserved, identifying them can be facilitated by a naming or numbering system that distinguishes the different stages of the project. This organization may specify, for example, the date, version number, or stage of completion of the work.

17.2. Scores and Composition Documents
Scores are an important part of the documentation of the creative process when a work is written or orchestrated in notated form. Significant versions of a score may be preserved to track changes in the composition, arrangement, and orchestration.

These documents may include sketches, working scores, revised scores, conductors’ scores, separate parts, or versions prepared for performance. They may also contain instructions, annotations, or corrections that help explain certain decisions made during the work’s development.

Preserving these elements makes it possible, in particular, to distinguish the musical motif created by the composer from subsequent stages of formatting or production. It thus constitutes a direct record of the work of composition and orchestration.

17.3. Source Files
Source files refer to the working documents from which a work or part of it was developed. They may include musical notation files, working documents, production projects, MIDI files, recorded audio files, or any other files directly used during the process.

Where possible and appropriate, important source files may be preserved in a state that allows the project to be reconstructed in its working form. Preserving them can be particularly useful when a work needs to be revised, adapted, reorchestrated, or produced in another format at a later date.

Source files can also help document the project timeline and the various stages of its development. However, they are only one element of documentation among others and are not necessarily preserved in their entirety for every project.

17.4. DAW Projects
Projects created in a digital audio workstation can provide a particularly detailed record of the production phase. They may contain the track layout, MIDI sequences, virtual instruments used, audio processing, automations, effects, mixing settings, and the various resources required to complete the project.

Preserving a DAW project can thus help reconstruct the production structure of a work at a given point in time. It can also show how the various elements were organized, programmed, and processed prior to the final export.

When several significant versions of a project are preserved, they can document changes made to the mix, arrangement, orchestration, or programming. DAW projects therefore serve as a form of technical documentation of the production process, complementing sheet music and other compositional documents.

17.5. MIDI Files
MIDI files may be retained when they constitute a significant part of the production process. In particular, they may document the notes, rhythms, velocities, controllers, and other information used to control virtual instruments or organize certain musical parts.

These files make it possible to preserve a digital representation of certain musical creations independently of the final audio output. They can also facilitate the revision or reuse of material in another version of the work.

The presence of MIDI files in the documentation does not mean that their content was generated automatically. As part of the process described in this charter, the MIDI data used for the works is created, recorded, programmed, or edited under the composer’s supervision.

17.6. Audio Exports
Audio exports allow you to preserve the various stages of transforming a project into a finished audio production. Depending on your needs, these may include demos, working versions, pre-mixes, intermediate mixes, versions for approval, or final files.

Preserving certain audio versions can help compare the evolution of the sound and understand the decisions made during mixing and mastering. It can also serve as a backup when a previous version needs to be consulted or restored.

However, exports are not necessarily retained in their entirety. Retention may be limited to versions that are of real interest for tracking the project’s progress, particularly key milestones or versions that have undergone substantial changes.

17.7. Creation Dates and Timeline
When available, the dates of creation, modification, export, or validation can help establish the timeline of the process. The dates associated with files, versions, scores, or projects can thus help pinpoint the various stages in the development of a work.

The timeline can be supplemented, where relevant, with version information, working notes, or details regarding major changes made. The goal is not necessarily to produce an exhaustive log, but to maintain a timeline that is sufficiently clear to track the project’s overall progress.

Metadata automatically recorded by software can also serve as useful documentation, provided it is reliable and preserved. However, it is not considered conclusive evidence on its own and may be supplemented by other elements when necessary.

17.8. Modifications and Revisions
Significant modifications made to a work may, where relevant, be identified or preserved. These may include, in particular, changes to the melody, harmony, structure, orchestration, arrangement, programming, mixing, or mastering.

This documentation demonstrates that the work can evolve through successive cycles of reflection, listening, correction, and validation. It also serves as a record of the composer’s active involvement in the work’s development.

However, it is not necessary to document every minor change. The level of detail chosen may depend on the scope of the project, its complexity, its stage of completion, and the value of preserving certain stages. Traceability must remain compatible with the reality of the creative process and not become a disproportionate burden.

17.9. Final Versions
When a work is considered complete, one or more final versions may be identified in order to clearly distinguish the approved result from previous working versions. This identification may apply to the final score, the final audio file, files intended for distribution, and, where relevant, the corresponding source projects.

The final version is the result selected by the composer following the various stages of composition, writing, orchestration, production, mixing, mastering, and quality control. It may be accompanied by information identifying its approval date or version number.

This distinction between working versions and final versions helps avoid any ambiguity when a single project has undergone numerous changes. It also facilitates the preservation, archiving, and future reuse of the work.

17.10. Preservation and Organization
Documentation items can be organized in a way that maintains a consistent structure across different projects. Organizing by work, then by document type or production stage, can make it easier to locate sheet music, source files, DAW projects, audio exports, and final versions later on.

Where appropriate, backups can be created to reduce the risk of data loss or corruption. Storing multiple copies or on multiple media may be considered for projects of particular importance.

Documentation can also be stored in formats that allow for future access as much as possible. However, it is important to take into account changes in software, file formats, and operating systems, which may make some older projects more difficult to open. When necessary, exports or copies in more widely compatible formats can supplement the source files.

17.11. The Documentary Value of Traceability
Preserving these various elements makes it possible to establish a history of the work carried out and to demonstrate that a work has an identifiable creative process. Scores, source files, DAW projects, MIDI data, audio exports, successive versions, and chronological information—when available—can form a body of documentation that allows the main stages of the work’s development to be reconstructed.

However, this documentation should not be presented as an absolute legal guarantee or as automatic proof of all aspects of a work’s origin. It constitutes, above all, a documentary record of the creative process. Its value depends on the quality, consistency, integrity, and preservation of the relevant elements.

Traceability thus complements the statements in this charter. Rather than merely asserting that works are composed and produced by their creator, it allows—when the relevant elements are preserved—for a concrete demonstration of the various stages through which a work was developed.

17.12. General Principle
The composer seeks to preserve, to the extent reasonable and when relevant, the significant elements that document his or her creations. This documentation may include successive versions, scores, source files, DAW projects, MIDI files, audio exports, dates, modifications, and final versions.

The goal is to maintain a coherent and traceable history of the creative process, from the first significant stages through to the final product. This approach enhances the transparency of the process without requiring the exhaustive preservation of every temporary element or minor modification.

Documentation and traceability thus constitute a natural extension of the principles of transparency, human creation, and artistic control established by this charter. They make it possible to preserve not only the final result of a work but also part of its creative history.

18 • Statement of Authenticity

The purpose of this statement is to formalize the principles according to which musical works are conceived, developed, and produced. It summarizes the commitments set forth in the various sections of this charter and aims to describe, in a clear, factual, and transparent manner, the origin of the musical work presented under the composer’s name.

The works I publish are the result of my own musical creative process. They are conceived, developed, and finalized based on my artistic, musical, and technical decisions. The melodies, harmonies, structures, arrangements, orchestrations, scores, and production choices are determined as part of my creative work. The digital tools used in this process serve to write, program, record, edit, produce, mix, or finalize the music; they do not replace my involvement in the decisions that determine the content of the work.

18.1. Human Creativity
The creation of musical works is based on a human process in which the primary artistic decisions are made by the composer. Musical ideas are explored, developed, evaluated, and modified throughout the composition process. Melody, harmony, structure, arrangement, orchestration, notation, and production choices are developed and finalized by the composer personally.

The composer may experiment with different possibilities, abandon certain ideas, return to a previous stage, compare several versions, and gradually modify their work until the desired result is achieved. This process of exploration, experimentation, revision, and validation is an integral part of the creative process.

18.2. No Generative Artificial Intelligence
No generative artificial intelligence is involved in my music-making process.

This statement means that no generative artificial intelligence system is used to generate, suggest, or produce on my behalf the musical elements that make up the works, including melodies, harmonies, structures, arrangements, orchestrations, scores, or musical content intended to be incorporated into the published works.

This statement does not constitute a value judgment on artificial intelligence technologies, their uses, or the practices of other creators. It merely describes the creative process followed for the works covered by this charter. The decision not to incorporate generative artificial intelligence into this process stems from a desire to preserve a creative approach based on the composer’s direct involvement and control.

18.3. Use of Digital Tools
This statement does not imply that the creative process is carried out without digital tools. Music notation software, digital audio workstations, virtual instruments, orchestral libraries, virtual synthesizers, MIDI keyboards, mixing and mastering software, audio effects, sound samples, and recording tools may be used as part of the creative and production process.

These tools are considered technical means for realizing the composer’s musical decisions. Their function may be comparable to that of an instrument, a notation medium, a recording device, or production equipment. Their use does not imply that they autonomously determine the artistic content of the work.

When a virtual instrument or sound library is used, the musical motif it reproduces is determined by the composer. Similarly, when software automatically performs a technical operation, this function should not be confused with the autonomous generation of the work’s musical content.

18.4. Artistic Control
The composer retains control over the key decisions in the creative process. In particular, the composer decides what should be composed, modified, retained, deleted, arranged, orchestrated, recorded, programmed, edited, mixed, or finalized.

This control also applies during the revision phases. A work may go through numerous versions before reaching its final form. The composer evaluates the results obtained, identifies elements that need improvement, and decides on the changes to be made. The final version is thus the result of human selection and approval.

The use of automated technical functions available in production software does not alter this principle. An automated operation may execute a task defined by the user, but the decision to use that operation, adjust its parameters, evaluate the result, and determine whether or not to retain it remains under the composer’s control.

18.5. Originality and Influences
Works may be rooted in a musical culture, influenced by composers, works, genres, traditions, or aesthetics, and draw on various sources of inspiration. Recognizing these influences does not mean that the published works constitute reproductions of existing creations.

The composer seeks to transform these influences and inspirations into personal creations by developing their own motifs and making their own choices. In doing so, they distinguish between artistic influence, inspiration, reference, or homage and the reproduction of a work.

When elements from pre-existing works are intentionally used in a specific context, their nature must be distinguished from the composer’s original material, and the conditions governing their use must be respected. This statement does not seek to deny the existence of musical influences; rather, it affirms the commitment to create without presenting as original content whose origin has been intentionally concealed.

18.6. Documentation and Traceability
Where relevant, the various significant stages of the process can be documented using successive versions, scores, source files, DAW projects, MIDI files, audio exports, creation or modification dates, and final versions.

These elements can help maintain a history of a work’s development and demonstrate that it is the result of a progressive process of composition and production. The purpose of documentation is not to record every action or minor modification, but to preserve the significant elements that allow one to understand the project’s evolution.

Traceability thus serves as a practical complement to this statement. When the documents are preserved, it provides concrete evidence of the work performed, rather than limiting transparency to a mere statement of principle.

18.7. Scope of the Statement
This statement pertains to the music-creation process described in this charter and to the works to which it applies. It describes the practices actually adopted by the composer and does not constitute either a general statement on all existing technologies or a position on the practices of other artists.

Nor does it claim to constitute a legal certification or an absolute guarantee regarding the absence of any unintentional resemblance to an existing work. It formalizes a creative approach and practices: the works are composed and produced under the composer’s control, without the intervention of generative artificial intelligence in the creation of the musical content that constitutes them.

This charter may be updated if the creative process evolves. Any substantial changes to methods, tools, or forms of collaboration may then be documented to ensure that the charter remains consistent with the practices actually in use.

18.8. Final Statement
Accordingly, the composer declares that the works published under this charter are the result of his or her own musical creative process and that the key decisions regarding their composition, writing, arrangement, orchestration, production, and finalization are made under his or her control.

No generative artificial intelligence is involved in the musical creation process. This declaration is formulated as a factual description of the working method. It is not intended to condemn, judge, or regulate the practices of other creators, but simply to provide transparency regarding the process by which the composer’s own works are conceived and produced.

The composer’s goal is to preserve a personal, identifiable, and documented musical creation in which technical tools are used as means to serve a human artistic approach. This charter thus constitutes a commitment to transparency regarding the origin, development, production, and finalization of the works that are conceived and published.